

A Buyer Needs to Sell Their Home First: Should You Accept a Contingent Offer on Your Venice or Englewood Home?

Luxury Homes By Carol Blog
Should you accept an offer on your Venice or Englewood home if the buyer has to sell their own house first?
Sometimes, yes. A contingent offer can be worth taking when the buyer's home is already listed and priced well, the terms are short, and you keep marketing your home with a kick-out clause and a backup contract in place.
The offer comes in on a Thursday evening. The price is good. The buyers loved the lanai, they loved the golf cart ride to the beach, and their agent says they are serious. Then you get to the page that says they need to sell their home in Ohio first.
That one line changes the whole offer. You are no longer just asking whether these buyers can close. You are asking whether some other buyer, a thousand miles away, will buy a house you have never seen, on a timeline you do not control.
Plenty of sellers in Venice, Englewood, Beachwalk by Manasota Key and Wellen Park say no on reflex. Others say yes and then sit off the market for two months while the deal slowly falls apart. Neither move is the smart one. Here's what I'd do instead, step by step, using the tools already built into the Florida contract.
Why you are seeing more of these offers right now
Our buyers are mostly moving here from somewhere else. A lot of them pay cash, but many of those cash buyers are cash only after their house up north sells. That is exactly the buyer who writes a contingent offer.
The national picture is also slower than it was. The National Association of Realtors reported that pending home sales fell 4.7% from September to October 2026, and 16.7% from a year earlier, in its October 2026 Pending Home Sales report. When fewer buyers are signing contracts, more of the ones who do show up have a house of their own to sell.
Deals are also getting a little shakier once they are signed. In its September 2026 Realtors Confidence Index, NAR found that 7% of contracts were terminated in the prior three months and 16% had a delayed settlement. Those are national numbers, not Sarasota County numbers, but they tell you why the structure of your contract matters as much as the price.
So the question is not whether you will ever see a contingent offer. You probably will. The question is whether you will know how to turn one into a deal that protects you.
What a home sale contingency actually means for you
When a buyer's offer depends on selling their current home, they get a way out if that sale does not happen by a set date. In Florida, that promise usually lives in a rider attached to the standard contract.
Most residential deals here are written on the Florida Realtors and Florida Bar contract forms. Those forms come with lettered riders you can add. The one for this situation is Rider V, Sale of Buyer's Property. According to Florida Realtors' summary of the optional riders, Rider V gives buyers a potential way out of the transaction if they cannot sell their existing property. Florida Realtors also notes that buyers with a financing contingency who need to sell another property to buy yours must use this rider.
That last point matters to you. If a financed buyer needs their sale to qualify for the loan, and nobody added Rider V, the contract does not tell the truth about the risk you are taking. A clear Rider V is better for you than a vague promise.
The three kinds of contingent buyer
Not every contingent offer carries the same risk. I sort them into three buckets before I say anything else to a seller.
- Their home is under contract. Someone has already agreed to buy it. The risk is that their buyer falls through. This is the lowest-risk version.
- Their home is listed but not under contract. It is on the market, with photos, showings and a price. The risk depends heavily on whether that price makes sense for their market.
- Their home is not listed yet. They plan to sell soon. This is the highest-risk version, and it deserves the most protection, or a polite no.
Ask your agent to find out which bucket you are in before you counter. It changes everything that follows.
The real cost of saying yes the wrong way
The danger with a contingent offer is not that it might fall apart. Any contract can fall apart. The danger is the time your home spends tied up while it does.
Think about what happens if you accept a plain contingent offer with no other protection. Your listing goes to pending. Showings slow down or stop. Buyers scrolling the MLS skip right past you. Weeks go by. Then the buyer's house in Michigan does not sell, they cancel, and you are back on the market having lost your freshest selling window.
In Venice and Englewood, that lost window can hurt more than it would elsewhere. Our buyer traffic builds as seasonal residents come back for winter. If your contingent deal eats up December and January and then dies, you relaunch into a busier field of listings with a price history that now looks a little tired.
Your carrying costs keep running the whole time too. Taxes, insurance, HOA dues, utilities, lawn and pool service. None of that pauses because you have a contract.
Your three protection tools: Rider V, Rider X and Rider W
Here is the good news. The Florida forms already give sellers a way to say yes while keeping the market working for them. Florida Realtors' associate general counsel described the approach in a May 2026 article on protecting backup offers, calling it a way for sellers to accept the best offer while protecting themselves in case it falls through.
Rider V: the buyer's contingency, with real dates
Rider V is the buyer's protection, but you control how loose or tight it is through negotiation. Push for a firm deadline for the buyer's sale to close, not just a hope that it sells someday. A short, specific window is the single most valuable term you can negotiate on a contingent offer.
Rider X: the kick-out clause
Rider X is your protection. Under the kick-out clause, you keep the right to show the property and enter into bona fide backup contracts. If you sign a backup contract, you show it to your first buyer with the price and buyer details blacked out.
Your first buyer then has to decide. Florida Realtors describes this as a "put up or shut up" moment. Within the window set in the rider, they must make an additional deposit and waive their contingencies, including the sale of their own property. If they do, they are committed to close, and their deposits are at risk if they do not. If they do not make that additional deposit, their contract ends, their original deposit is returned, and you move to the next buyer in line.
That is the whole point. A buyer who is bluffing about their finances gets called on it. A buyer who truly can close shows you by putting more money down.
Rider W: the backup contract
Rider W is the companion form for your backup buyer. Florida Realtors notes the kick-out clause is designed to work together with the backup contract, though many agents use one without the other.
Under Rider W, you and the backup buyer pick a drop-dead date. After that date, the backup buyer no longer has to buy if they are moved into first position. The backup buyer can also walk away any time before you notify them that they are in first place.
One detail most people miss: under Rider W, the effective date of the backup contract is the day you notify the backup buyer that they are now first. That is the date their inspection period and deposit deadlines start running. Your agent should explain this clearly to everyone so nobody is surprised.
Another tip from that same Florida Realtors article: you do not have to choose the second-highest price as your backup. You already locked in one strong offer. You are free to pick the backup most likely to actually close.
How to read a contingent offer before you counter
When one of these lands, I go through the same short checklist with every seller. It takes about ten minutes and it saves weeks of grief.
- Where is their home in the process? Under contract, listed, or not listed yet.
- Is their list price realistic? Ask your agent to pull up their listing and recent sales nearby. A home priced well above its neighbors is a warning sign.
- How long have they been on the market? A home that has been sitting for months is a different risk than one that just went live.
- How much equity do they need from their sale? A buyer who needs every dollar from their sale has less room if their price drops.
- What is their deposit? A meaningful deposit tells you they are invested. A tiny one tells you they are shopping.
- Is there proof of financing or funds? If they are borrowing, ask for a solid pre-approval from a licensed lender. If they are paying cash after their sale, ask what the cash plan looks like.
- What is the closing date? Does it line up with your plans, or does it stretch past when you need to be gone?
When a contingent offer is worth taking
I tell sellers to give a contingent offer real consideration when most of these are true:
- The buyer's home is under contract, or listed at a sensible price with good activity.
- The price and terms are clearly stronger than anything else you have.
- Your home has been on the market a while and showing traffic is light.
- You can live with a closing a bit further out.
- You are willing to keep showing the home under a kick-out clause.
In that situation, a well-built contingent contract is often better than waiting for a perfect buyer who may not come. You lock in a solid offer and keep your options open at the same time.
When to say no, or ask for more
A contingent offer deserves a firm counter, or a pass, when:
- The buyer's home is not listed yet and they have no clear plan to list it.
- Their list price looks unrealistic for their market.
- You have other offers, or strong showing activity, without contingencies.
- You need to close by a specific date, for example because you are under contract on your next home.
- The buyer refuses a kick-out clause.
That last one tells you a lot. A buyer who is confident in their sale usually does not mind a kick-out clause, because they plan to close anyway. A buyer who fights it is asking you to carry all of their risk.
Terms to ask for in your counteroffer
You do not have to accept a contingent offer as written. Here is what I would put on the table:
- A short, firm deadline for the buyer's sale to close.
- A requirement that their home be listed within a few days, if it is not already on the market.
- A kick-out clause (Rider X) so you can keep showing and accept a backup.
- A meaningful additional deposit the buyer must make if you trigger the kick-out.
- Regular updates on their listing, showings and any offers they receive.
- A price or terms that reflect your extra risk. You are giving them time and flexibility. That has value.
Every one of these is negotiable, and every one should be written into the contract, not promised on the phone. If any contract language is unclear, that is a question for a Florida real estate attorney before you sign.
Keep your home in front of buyers while you wait
A kick-out clause only works if you keep marketing. Here is how I handle it for my sellers.
Your listing stays visible to buyers and agents, with clear status so nobody thinks the home is gone. Showings continue. Cooperating agents know you will entertain a backup offer. I personally video the home so out-of-state buyers can tour it from their couch, which matters in a market where so many buyers live somewhere else.
The goal is simple. If your first buyer's sale stalls, you want another buyer already lined up, not a cold restart. If you are curious how I plan marketing for a sale from day one, my selling page walks through the approach.
A quick example of how this plays out
Here is an illustration with made-up details, just to show the moving parts. A seller in Englewood accepts an offer from buyers who need to sell their home in Illinois. Their home is listed but not under contract. The seller counters with a firm deadline for the Illinois sale to close, a kick-out clause, and an additional deposit if the kick-out is triggered. The buyers agree.
Three weeks later, a second buyer with no home to sell makes an offer. The seller signs it as a backup contract with a drop-dead date. The first buyers get notice. Their Illinois home still has no offer, so they choose not to put up the extra deposit. Their contract ends, their original deposit goes back to them, and the backup buyer moves into first position.
The seller never went back to square one. That is what good structure buys you.
Insurance, inspections and the rest still apply
A contingent offer does not replace any other part of a Florida deal. Your buyer will still have an inspection period. If they are financing, there will be an appraisal and a loan approval period. Insurance on our coast is still a big question for any buyer, especially on an older roof.
Each of those steps can move a date. When you stack a home sale contingency on top of them, small delays add up. Build a little breathing room into your own plans, and keep your homeowners coverage and utilities active until the day you close.
If you are selling one Florida home and buying another, also think about how the timing lines up with your homestead exemption and any portability you plan to use. That is a question for your county property appraiser and a tax professional, and it is worth asking early.
Frequently asked questions
What is a kick-out clause in a Florida real estate contract?
It is a rider, Rider X on the Florida Realtors and Florida Bar forms, that lets the seller keep showing the home and accept backup contracts after taking a contingent offer. If a backup contract is signed, the first buyer must make an additional deposit and waive contingencies within the set window, or their contract ends and their original deposit is returned.
Can I accept a backup offer while my home is under contract in Florida?
Yes, if your contract allows it. The Florida forms include Rider W for backup contracts, which sets a drop-dead date for the backup buyer and starts their deadlines on the day you notify them they are in first position. It works best paired with a kick-out clause on your first contract.
Should I accept a contingent offer if the buyer's home is not listed yet?
Be careful. An unlisted home is the highest-risk version of a contingent offer. If you consider it at all, ask for a requirement that the home be listed within a few days, a short deadline for their sale to close, and a kick-out clause so you can keep marketing.
Do I lose my place on the market if I accept a contingent offer?
You can, if the contract has no kick-out clause. With a kick-out clause, you can keep showing your home and accept a backup, so a stalled deal does not mean starting over. Talk with your agent about how your listing status and showings will be handled.
Got a contingent offer on your table?
If you are selling in Venice, Englewood, Beachwalk by Manasota Key or Wellen Park and a buyer needs to sell their home first, let's look at it together before you sign anything. I'll help you size up their sale, build in the right protections, and keep your home in front of buyers while you wait.
Fill out my contact form and tell me where your offer stands. Let's do it!
Have a great day!
Carol Burdelik
Luxury Realtor • ADTV Host • Coastal Lifestyle Expert
LPT Realty, LLC | FL License SL3549489
Serving Venice, Englewood, Beachwalk by Manasota Key, Wellen Park, and Sarasota, Charlotte, and Manatee Counties
Sources: Florida Realtors, "Think You Know Optional Clauses, Riders and Addenda?" (September 2023) and "Two Forms Can Protect Backup Offers" (May 2026); National Association of Realtors, September 2026 Realtors Confidence Index and October 2026 Pending Home Sales report. This post is for general information only and reflects what was known as of November 22, 2026.
Carol Burdelik is a licensed Florida real estate Sales Associate, not a CPA, attorney, lender, or insurance agent. Nothing in this post is tax, legal, financing, or insurance advice. Contract riders and terms vary, so review your own contract with a Florida real estate attorney before you sign.


Featured Articles
Trending Articles from Southwest Florida’s Top Real Estate Team
Stay updated with our most popular real estate and luxury lifestyle articles.

Client Feedback
Read what previous homeowners have said about working with us.

Let's Connect
Get in Touch
We’re here to assist you with your real estate needs.
Say Hello
Reach out to us anytime.
Office
Luxury Homes by Carol
26040 Seastone Dr.
Englewood, FL 34223

Pushing You Forward
Our Team
Meet the dedicated professionals behind your real estate journey.

@CarolBurdelik on YouTube
Latest Youtube Videos
Get the latest videos by Carol Burdelik on her YouTube channel.


Get Started
Start Your Luxury Property Journey Today
Contact Carol for a personalized consultation and discover your dream waterfront property in Florida.














